How do dogs “see” with their noses? – Alexandra Horowitz


“Hi, Bob.” “Morning, Kelly. The tulips looks great.” Have you ever wondered
how your dog experiences the world? Here’s what she sees. Not terribly interesting. But what she smells,
that’s a totally different story. And it begins at her wonderfully
developed nose. As your dog catches
the first hints of fresh air, her nose’s moist, spongy outside helps
capture any scents the breeze carries. The ability to smell
separately with each nostril, smelling in stereo, helps to determine the direction
of the smell’s source so that within the first
few moments of sniffing, the dog starts to become aware of not
just what kind of things are out there but also where they’re located. As air enters the nose, a small fold of tissue
divides it into two separate folds, one for breathing
and one just for smelling. This second airflow enters a region filled with highly specialized
olfactory receptor cells, several hundred millions of them,
compaired to our five million. And unlike our clumsy way of breathing
in and out through the same passage, dogs exhale through slits
at the side of their nose, creating swirls of air that help
draw in new odor molecules and allow odor concentration to build up
over mulitple sniffs. But all that impressive nasal architecture
wouldn’t be much help without something to process the loads
of information the nose scoops up. And it turns out that the olfactory system
dedicated to proessing smells takes up many times more relative
brain area in dogs than in humans. All of this allows dogs to distinguish and remember a staggering
variety of specific scents at concentrations up to 100 million times
less than what our noses can detect. If you can smell a spritz of perfume
in a small room, a dog would have no trouble smelling it
in an enclosed stadium and distinguishing its ingredients,
to boot. And everything in the street,
every passing person or car, any contents of the neighbor’s trash, each type of tree, and all the birds and insects in it has a distinct odor profile telling
your dog what it is, where it is, and which direction it’s moving in. Besides being much
more powerful than ours, a dog’s sense of smell can pick up things
that can’t even be seen at all. A whole separate olfactory system, called the vomeronasal organ,
above the roof of the mouth, detects the hormones all animals,
Including humans, naturally release. It lets dogs identify potential mates, or distinguish between friendly
and hostile animals. It alerts them to our various
emotional states, and it can even tell them
when someone is pregnant or sick. Because olfaction is more primal
than other senses, bypassing the thalamus to connect
directly to the brain structures involving emotion and instinct, we might even say a dog’s perception
is more immediate and visceral than ours. But the most amazing thing about
your dog’s nose is that it can traverse time. The past appears in tracks
left by passersby, and by the warmth
of a recently parked car where the residue of where you’ve been
and what you’ve done recently. Landmarks like fire hydrants and trees are aromatic bulletin boards
carrying messages of who’s been by, what they’ve been eating, and how they’re feeling. And the future is in the breeze, alerting them to something or someone
approaching long before you see them. Where we see and hear something
at a single moment, a dog smells an entire story
from start to finish. In some of the best examples
of canine-human collaboration, dogs help us by sharing
and reacting to those stories. They can respond with kindness
to people in distress, or with aggression to threats because stress and anger
manifest as a cloud of hormones recognizable to the dog’s nose. With the proper training, they can even alert us
to invisible threats ranging from bombs to cancer. As it turns out, humanity’s best friend is not one who experiences
the same things we do, but one whose incredible nose reveals
a whole other world beyond our eyes.

100 thoughts on “How do dogs “see” with their noses? – Alexandra Horowitz

  1. Thank you – this made me appreciate the importance of dogs having the opportunity to get outside their own yard and smell different smells. Atticus and I go for a lot more walks now.

  2. The point about time is what fascinates me about this. I can see my dog can smell the recent history of where we go. It would be really interesting to know what that feels like.

  3. I am not convinced that dogs read emotions through scent. If that were the case, wolves should be every bit as capable. Yet by my understanding, wolves can't read emotion as well. So I think that it is more likely that sight and hearing play a significant role in a dog's empathetic ability.

  4. They can smell the past? And emotions? Haha so next time we all see a "Lost Dog" sign we now know they just escaped.

  5. that explains why my neighbor's dog (and my best friend when i was a kid) came running to me when i got injured.

  6. After watching this video again, I find it funny that the camera in Sony Aibo (which is a robotic pet dog) has been placed in its nose, and not its eyes!

  7. What a fascinating video. As a fellow dog lover, Thank you! Something else I have always wondered is why do they lick humans so much?

  8. May I please use this video for my class? This video is very useful and students will understand well if I use it.

  9. One question; if thier sniffers are sooo strong, why do they push their noses against orher dogs butts to get a sniff?

  10. Yet the Prohpet Mohammed "banned" dogs from the homes? wow! truly what respect to the creator? (if there is one)

  11. If dogs can smell things from a mile away, why do they need to smell each other's bums from a cm away? (Paraphrasing Neil Degrasse Tyson)

  12. This is why the self awareness mirror test doesn't seem like the best method. Dogs cant recognise themselves in mirror. But then again we cannot recognise ourselves by scent.

  13. In English, we can directly describe how things look (ex: this is green), or we can say that it looks like something else (this looks like an apple). There are a lot fewer direct description words for smell, and we usually describe smells by saying what something smells like. This is because most humans do not rely on the sense of smell as much as sight, so we have more descriptive words for sight. However, dogs have a relatively strong sense of smell and worse eyesight, so if they had a language, I can’t help but wonder whether they would have a lot more words to describe smell that we humans will never be able to understand. (Just imagine a dog being like “your apple smells green”)

  14. Scent discrimination and scent retention are vital to the dogs daily life. They're primarily olfactory and humans primarily visual.

  15. Huh — had no idea they exhaled out of a different opening in their noses! How weird. . .but hey, if it helps their snoots do their thing. . .

  16. Wow, your video was very well done. I learned a lot even though we do not have a dog but, many cats instead.

  17. Watched this while my dog lay on my lap, right before he’s sniffing around even though I’ve got no treat for him. Great bonding video!

  18. fake!!! dogs can not smeell very very dog! end they have poor eye site!!! go end get a cat!!

  19. it is not a contest or statistical issue between dog brains and human brains. A dog is a dog and was developed by humans thousands of years in the past. A dog is not like a human; a dog is much closer to a wolf or fox or coyote (all are canids).

  20. ba.

    ha ba ba.

    ha ba ba d'ga da.

    ha ba ba da da ba.

    ha ba ba da ga da ga.

    ha da da.

    ha ba ba,

    ha ba ba d'ga d'ga.

    bah.

    BAH.

    bahbahbah.

    bah bah bah bah.

    bah bah bah bah bah.

    bah. bah.

    ba. ha ba ba.

    ha ba ba ba ba.

    ba! ba ba ba ba ba.

    waah.

    hawahwah.

    haaaAAh.

    haaah.

    hawawa.

    hAaaah.

    ha.

    ha da ba da ga?

    habwabwabbw:

    ha ba ba ba

    hawawwa,

    haaaaaaah.

    ha da ba da.

    haah.

    hawaawaawa,

    hawawaawaa.

    ba wa.

    ha da dis?

    ba.

    badadega?

    ba Da deh duh daa deh

    ba ga da ba ga

    hah buh deh gaah de ba daa duh

    hah dah baah

  21. Is the sense of smell in humans weaker due to our dependence on dogs to be …our finetuned nose? Possibly freeing up our other senses to be more sensitive?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *